About Us

About Cooperstown Pins

At Cooperstown Pins, we design and create custom trading pins that capture team pride and tournament spirit. We specialize in soft enamel, hard enamel, and unique baseball trading pins with features like glitter, danglers, and glow effects. Our goal is to provide every team with standout designs and high-quality pins that make trading unforgettable.

2025 Mavericks Robot Glitter Neon Cut Outs Baseball About Cooperstown Enamel Pin

What We do

Design and Manufacture

Cooperstown Pins designs and manufactures high-quality custom trading pins from start to finish. Our team transforms your ideas into bold, creative designs and produces durable enamel pins that are perfect for tournaments, trading, and collecting.

2025 365 Shockers Neon Baseball About Cooperstown Enamel Pin

Soft Enamel Cooperstown Pins

Soft enamel Cooperstown pins feature vibrant colors, bold textures, and affordable designs perfect for trading at tournaments.

2025 EKB Knights Baseball About Cooperstown Enamel Pin

Hard Enamel Cooperstown Pins

Hard enamel Cooperstown pins offer a smooth, polished finish with lasting durability and a premium look for every trade.

Design Process

The design process for Cooperstown trading pins begins with your team’s vision. Whether you already have a mascot, logo, or just a rough idea, our team will work with you to gather the details that make your pin unique. You’ll share colors, text, artwork, and any special features you’d like to include, setting the foundation for your custom trading pin.

Once we have your ideas, our professional designers get to work transforming them into a digital proof. This proof shows your design in full detail, including pin type (soft enamel or hard enamel), colors, and any extras like glitter or danglers. You’ll be able to see exactly how your Cooperstown trading pin will look before it goes into production.

Your feedback is an important part of the process. If you’d like adjustments to colors, text, or features, we’ll make revisions until the design matches your vision. Once you approve the final artwork, your pin design is locked in and ready for production.

After approval, we manufacture your pins with high-quality materials to ensure durability and a standout finish. Our team oversees every detail, from the enamel fill to the plating, to guarantee your Cooperstown trading pins meet top standards. Once complete, your pins are shipped directly to you, ready for trading, collecting, and showing off at tournaments.

[They] were incredible to work with! Chelsea went above and beyond to create exactly what our team wanted for Cooperstown!! She was so patient and helpful. She communicated so well through it the entire transaction. Also our banner and towel designers were so helpful! We received our pins, towels and banner weeks before expected! Such a fast turnaround!! They made the entire process run really smooth! Thanks again everyone at metro pins!!!

– Stephany Clark

They are easy to communicate and made our designs for Cooperstown pin trading come Alice! They were a hit of week 11 this year! Thank you from Velocity Baseball!

– Tara Lawhead

Excellent company to work with. Quick turnaround time, reasonable pricing and great customer service. Tiffany was so easy to work with and she makes sure you get what you need.

– Tony Kucharski

Greg and his team were great to work with! They were very responsive and helped us get our team pins made efficiently and with a great design. We will use them again!

– Kelsey Poe

To any team traveling to Cooperstown like our 12U baseball team or just looking to order trading pins, I highly recommend [them]. The pricing was the best I found and customer service was great to have a contact person to deal with on questions and details.

– Amy Johnston